Local History

Information, News, and features from Montauk Library’s local history collection.

A Tougher Time

  One of seven children, Sarah (King) Tuthill was sent at age 6 to Montauk to live with Loretta Dickinson, a friend of her mother’s who lived in “better circumstances” and had indicated that “she would like to have one of the girls.” In an oral history interview in 1967, when she was 81, Sarah… Read more »

Awaken to the Dawn Chorus

Joyous, I heard, while slowly borne along, From wakening birds, the early burst of song, Upspringing like a morning hymn, to rise And mingle with the worship of the skies. -J.A. Ayres, The Legends of Montauk, 1849 This time of year, the dawn chorus of birdsong combines mating, territorial, alarm, and location vocalizations from resident,… Read more »

‘Roaring ’20s,’ Indeed

IYKYK.  JK about “If you know you know.” We know which local girls are in this photo and are more than happy to share that information. But first consider identifying them on your own.  Two clues: The young ladies were wearing flapper costumes for a production of the “Baker’s Roaring ‘20s Scrapbook” at the Montauk… Read more »

Working Hard, Kicking Back

Working Hard, Kicking Back

There was a surprisingly glamorous whiff to fish on Montauk Harbor in the 1970s and early 1980s. The commercial dock, Gosman’s retail and wholesale seafood operation next door, the new Dock restaurant next door to that – for many, work was hard and physical, and opportunities to kick back were most welcome. These photos come… Read more »

Bicycle Race

Although cyclists ride year-round, springtime is the season associated with outdoor athletics.  This photograph from the collection of Al Holden was donated with the information, “Bike race start at Gosman’s.” Although undated, most likely this photograph was taken in the late 1970s.  George Watson, owner of the Dock, began launching annual athletic events from his… Read more »

Library Stories

Celebrate National Library Week with us by listening to stories from our oral history collection about the library’s history and the people involved over the years.  This year’s National Library Week theme is “Find Your Joy.”  We find joy in our community––in our founders, patrons, and dedicated volunteers who have helped our library grow from… Read more »

Keeping It Green and Clean

Keeping It Green and Clean

“I love Montauk and don’t want to see it ruined,” said an advertisement in the July 16, 1970, issue of the East Hampton Star. The ad included a mail-in coupon for donations to the Concerned Citizens of Montauk, a group that had recently formed to resist a proposed 1,500- home development of Indian Field. April… Read more »

Serving Tea and Independence

Serving Tea and Independence

In the 1910s and 1920s, tea rooms and tea houses dotted America’s new motorways, providing tea and light refreshments to traveling tourists. On the eastern end of Long Island, motorists driving through Montauk could find refuge at the Weeweecho Tea House situated on the southern bluffs overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. At that time when Montauk… Read more »

Throwback Thursday — A Friend to the Light

Throwback Thursday — A Friend to the Light

Vanished, it would seem, are the days when admission to any event cost less than ten dollars, as it did when Frank Borth designed this $1.75 ticket to tour the Montauk Lighthouse. A professional illustrator, he was a true friend to the Montauk Historical Society as well as other community organizations, including the fire department,… Read more »

Throwback Thursday — Remembering John Keeshan

Throwback Thursday — Remembering John Keeshan

Montauk is known for its cheerful community events and celebrations. Even in the off-season, events like the St. Patrick’s Day parade sponsored by the Montauk Friends of Erin and the annual Turkey Trot draw crowds from across Long Island and New England.  At last week’s East Hampton Town Board work session held at the Montauk… Read more »