Local History

Information, News, and features from Montauk Library’s local history collection.

Wooed and Wed In Lighthouse Tower

Wooed and Wed In Lighthouse Tower

In late October of 1903, a young couple joined hands in marriage atop the lighthouse tower. Their choice of the venue arose from their happenstance meeting there, when Evelyn Cook was visiting her aunt and uncle, Margaret and Captain James G. Scott, who was the lighthouse keeper living there at the time. The groom was… Read more »

‘A More Generous Time’

‘A More Generous Time’

  What do all these photos have in common?         A couple of hints. Think of one’s dismay at seeing a receiver dangling uselessly inside – a pretty sure sign of malfunction. Or think of one filling with rising water while Agents 86 and 99 struggle desperately to get out. The phone… Read more »

Ode to the Swamp Rose Mallow

Ode to the Swamp Rose Mallow

  During the dog days of summer, you will find splashes of pink dotting the roadsides throughout Montauk, especially in low-lying areas on the margins of wetlands and shorelines. These lush native displays belong to the swamp rose mallow or Hibiscus moscheutos, as it is known scientifically.  The swamp rose mallow, commonly called the hardy… Read more »

That ’70s Vibe

That ’70s Vibe

  Where were you in 1976? Did you get to witness the nation’s jubilant Bicentennial celebrations – all the tall ships and parades and Revolutionary War reenactments? Were you terrified by the release of the movie Jaws – and among the crowds who gathered on the Montauk docks to gawk at the massive creatures? Were… Read more »

Oral History Spotlight: Dean Phillippe

Oral History Spotlight: Dean Phillippe

Dean Phillippe, originally from Kansas City, Missouri, enlisted in the Air Force in the early 1960s to get ahead of a draft, completing basic training in Texas before being assigned to the 773rd Radar Squadron in Montauk. He traveled to Montauk by train, spending New Year’s Eve stranded at Penn Station after missing his connection…. Read more »

Vision on a Hill

Vision on a Hill

  A ghost from Montauk’s history perched on an inexorably vanishing shore – this painting depicts the McCaffray/Rheinstein windmill on what was known as Sandpiper Hill. The work most likely was painted by William A. Rogers in the 1930s. It came into the family of Harold Hone, who purchased property nearby in Ditch Plains in… Read more »

Throwback Thursday – Bob-E and the Book Fair

Throwback Thursday – Bob-E and the Book Fair

This post was originally published on July 3, 2024. It has been slightly updated to included the date of this year’s Friends of the Library Book Fair. Barbara Metzger (1944-2023) was an award-winning novelist, editor, writer of greeting card verses, artist, and longtime volunteer with the Friends of the Montauk Library. It was in that… Read more »

Main Street Staple

Main Street Staple

On the corner of Main Street and Carl Fisher Plaza, White’s Pharmacy was a magnet for Montauk kids in the 1930s, ‘40s, and ‘50s. For starters, it had a soda fountain and a great view of any action that was going down in town. “What the liquor store is now was Dick White’s drug store,”… Read more »

A Distinguished Summer Colony

“WHY, here is all the charm of England and Scotland, and less than three hours from New York!” The noted visitor, a traveler to many climes, stood high on a breeze-swept, green-clad hill at Montauk Beach, 125 miles out into the cool Atlantic on Long Island’s slender tip, and surveyed the alluring panorama before him…. Read more »

Blessing the Fleet

Blessing the Fleet

Montauk’s first Blessing of the Fleet – born as the “Blessing of the Boats” – was in 1956 and the brainchild of Vinnie Grimes, a charter boat captain and Navy veteran who’d seen Portuguese tuna fishermen blessing their boats before they headed out to sea on the West Coast. “It is an old European custom… Read more »