‘A More Generous Time’

Tow women posing at the end of a old-fashioned bar.
Kitty Erickson and Nell Wilson at Shagwong Tavern, date unknown. | McLaughlin Family Photographs, Montauk Library Archives

 

What do all these photos have in common?

Bar and restaurant, circa 1970s, with outdoor seating, glass rooftop.
Exterior of the Longboat restaurant, circa 1970s. | Sally Richardson Photos, Montauk Library Archives

 

Waterfront bar and restaurant, circa 1970s, with vintage cars parked outside.
Flying Fish restaurant, date unknown. | Ray Smith Collection, Montauk Library Archives

 

One-story motel with sign and phone booth outside, circa 1970s.
Sweeney’s Motel, date unknown. | Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives

 

1950s-era luncheonette with stools and tables.
Pilbro’s restaurant, circa 1950s. | Ellen Pilbro Johns Photos, Montauk Library Archives
Small Montauk Chamber of Commerce building, circa 1960s, with four people posting outside and flag flying next to phone booth.
Montauk Chamber of Commerce, 1960. | Dave Edwardes Collection, Montauk Library Archives
Larger Montauk Chamber of Commerce building with phone booth bank and metal trash pail outside.
Current Montauk Chamber of Commerce building, date unknown.| Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives

 

A couple of hints. Think of one’s dismay at seeing a receiver dangling uselessly inside – a pretty sure sign of malfunction. Or think of one filling with rising water while Agents 86 and 99 struggle desperately to get out.

The phone booth – or in British parlance, the “phone box” (like the red one featured in the 1983 film Local Hero) – once provided a place to duck into for shelter, a relatively secure setting for private melodrama and to report emergencies, an anonymous space to make prank calls and pursue criminal activities, a low-pressure chamber in which to collect one’s thoughts. In popular culture it was the booth that allowed Clark Kent to change costume without exposing himself, Get Smart agents to access CONTROL’s HQ, and Dr. Who to travel through time via TARDIS.

An enclosed “telephone cabinet” on wheels with a desk was reportedly patented in 1883. The first coin-operated payphone was installed in 1889 at a bank in Hartford, Connecticut, by William Gray, who came up with the design after nobody would let him use their phone to call a doctor for his wife. Over time phone booths evolved from wood to glass and metal and began to spring up outdoors as well as indoors. By 1960 the Bell System had installed its millionth payphone, and the payphone peaked at more than 2 million installments around 1995 to 2000.

Two aged newspaper clippings from the early 20th century.
Copy touting the rising popularity of coin-operated phones, including photos of a bank of public phones and of a fancy single booth, in the June 17, 1932 East Hampton Star. Also, an advertisement for a club car phone booth from the April 15, 1954 Star. | Courtesy of New York Historic Newspapers

 

Phone booths in Montauk often starred in the police logs. Responding on two separate occasions to reports of a robbery and then a shooting in the harbor area, police “found no shooting but noticed someone they described as ‘a short, fat subject at the phone booth’ by the Tipperary Inn,” then went on to charge the grown man with four counts of falsely reporting (by pay phone) an incident.

Unfortunately, public phones often fell victim to vandals and vehicles. 

“Several doors of the Sea and Sky Portel in Montauk were kicked in,” another log entry reported, in1986, “the glass of the phone booth was broken and the phone destroyed, it was discovered.”

 “Two men were seen walking up to a phone booth at the Ronjo Motel in Montauk at midnight Aug. 9,” went another report, in 1988. “One of them punched the glass pane on it, shattering it, then walked away.”

It was the growing popularity of the cellphone, however, that ultimately spelled the death of the payphone, which was meanwhile evolving into “hooded models” that protected the phone machinery and coin box while leaving the user exposed. The first cellphone call was placed in 1973. 

In 2018, it was estimated 100,000 payphones remained in the U.S., with roughly a fifth of them located in New York,” according to Wikipedia. “Four years later, NYC removed its last public one, though some private pay phones remained on public property, and four full-length booths still stood on the Upper West Side in May 2022.”

Montauk still has booth-less pay phones at Montauk Point State Park, one in the harbor area, and one – at least at last glance it was still there – against an exterior wall of the former White’s Drug and Department Store. 

Side-by-side photos of the Montauk Point restroom building with a bench and payphone outside and a closeup of the payphone.
At Montauk Point: The “last” payphone on Long Island. | Photos courtesy of Aimee Lusty

 

Meanwhile, the phone booth was not without its mourners.

“The demise of the phone booth is a blow to gracious living,” Uri Berliner wrote in a sort of obituary in the East Hampton Star in 1986.

He went on to call it “the end of a more generous time when public facilities were made to assist rather than thwart the citizenry.” 

Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.