Shopping Locally

Woman stands before refrigerator case with roasting pans hanging above.
The IGA opened at its present location on May 10, 1967, and this photo was taken when it reopened after a fire in 1988. It still has foil roasting pans if you need one for Thanksgiving. | Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives

 

Once upon a time Montauk didn’t have a supermarket that stayed open on Sunday afternoons, let alone one where you could shop Thanksgiving morning. Unknowingly deprived of Peapod or 7-Eleven-style convenience, locals planned their meals around the store’s hours or risked having to make a pilgrimage to the west.

Our Montauk IGA was born in the building near Martell’s that currently houses the Montauk Market and once housed Ping’s restaurant and Montauk TV. John J. Torr – later the owner of John’s Drive-In and the Crow’s Nest — opened the Montauk Super Market in that Main Street spot in July 1962.

Building housing "Super Market" with 1960s model cars parked outside.
The Montauk Super Market on Main Street where Montauk Market and Happy Bowls are today. Note that the building stood alone in the 1960s. | Dave Edwardes Collection, Montauk Library Archives
Supermarket interior
A Dave Edwardes photo of the original IGA’s interior. | Montauk Library Archives
Advertisement for Montauk I.G.A. Supermarket in guide book
Advertisement in the Montauk Guide and Cook Book published by the Montauk Chamber of Commerce, 1960

 

“The supermarket features a complete line of meats, groceries, and produce at popular prices,” was the tagline. By 1963 it was called the Sunbeam Supermarket; by 1966, John Torr wanted to focus on John’s Drive-In instead, so “he convinced his Coca-Cola delivery driver, my father, to buy the store,” John R. Capozzola said of his father, Frank Capozzola.

Frank convinced his cousin Eddie Heil to move with him to Montauk, and together they bought seven building lots where the current IGA supermarket is located. John’s uncle, Donald Cappy, built the store, which opened on May 10, 1967, to much fanfare.

Newspaper clipping of ribbon-cutting.
Starring local dignitaries and the two cousins and their families, the supermarket’s ribbon-cutting earned a spot in the May 18, 1967, issue of the East Hampton Star, available on newyorkhistoricnewspapers.org. “I asked if they had any facts and figures to hand out,” Arthur Roth wrote. “’Well the store has 8,000 square feet altogether, of which 5,000 is actually selling area,’ Frank said. ‘We have 2,100 different brand items, four check-outs and space in our parking lot for 60 cars.’”

 

The Star’s Arthur Roth covered the opening in great detail:

“I was introduced to the two young men who own the store, Frank Capozzola and Edward Heil,” he wrote. “I asked Edward if there was anything about his store that was different from other supermarkets.”

“’Certainly,’ he said with proprietorial pride, ‘unlike the others, our store isn’t paid for yet.’”

By the 1970s, Phil Dinkel and Robert Lachmann owned the “IGA Foodliner,” which for a number of Montauk teenagers was a first place of employment. Locals socialized with their neighbors in the aisles; second-home owners made it their first stop when they came into town.

Imagine the disappointment of the whole community when the IGA was ravaged by a fire in the spring of 1988. 

“Toothbrushes hung from racks like thin strings, other plastic items looked like stalactites and stalagmites …, vegetables were roasted in their bins, cash registers melted into counters, and plastic bottles were sculpted into varied shapes still holding their contents,” the Star reported.

And, soon after: “The blaze’s aftermath has meant a drive to Amagansett for Montauk shoppers. In combination with Amagansett IGA regulars, they have faced a supermarket that at times looked more like one in Poland than the Hamptons.”

When the supermarket opened again that July, however, it had been expanded and so had its inventory. Al Holden took a trove of photos whose negatives are preserved in the Montauk Library Archives.

Woman pushes cart with child in it toward front of store shrouded in a tarp.
A shroud still covered the front of the store when it reopened for business. | Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives
People in shopping aisle.
The store was expanded after being all but totaled in the fire, which was believed to have been caused by defective wiring near an ice cube freezer at the front of the store. | Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives
Man at deli counter.
The deli counter looks much the same in 2026, almost 40 years after the fire. | Al Holden Collection, Montauk Library Archives

 

Robert Stark took ownership of the IGA in 1996 and more than 20 years later, in 2018, sold it to Michael Bozzuto of Bozzuto’s Inc., whom he described as a longtime friend. 

“I wanted to make sure that my people kept their jobs and I’ve been very proud to be an I.G.A. owner, and I want it to stay that way,” Stark told the Star at the time. 

“I hope that the consumers who’ve been happy shopping here know that nothing is going to change.”

Let’s raise a fork to continuity! Bon appetit and happy Thanksgiving!

Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.